tallship wrote the following post Fri, 09 Dec 2022 01:13:49 +0200


@downey

Mastodon IS NOT the #Fediverse!

The #BDFL of that project saying it's is "vital" illustrates the branding philosophy and corporate, ego driven mindset behind so many PRs and requests that have repeatedly been rejected by an overwhelming amount of Fediverse users and developers - just look at how many 👎 "thumbs down" 👎 reactions his post received (that is rarely seen on GitHub).

His language and marketing have been largely successful, confusing newcomers during this Twitter egress (including media coverage) and conflating just what the Fediverse and mastodon are...

People are saying, "I just joined mastodon!" - NO, you did not. You just joined the "Fediverse", by creating an account on a mastodon server. Even newcomers creating accounts on #Friendica and #Pleroma servers are often seen saying this, and it needs to "STOP".

The Fediverse is the network they are joining, and mastodon is just one of a dozen or so viable platforms that people can use to do so.

Truth be told, mastodon is one of the least feature complete Fediverse server platforms, lacking in many of the most basic social networking tools and features that most other popular server platforms introduced ages ago.

It doesn't even render Markdown, have have quotable boosting, only introduced editing of posts a couple of weeks back, and has a hard coded limit of a paltry 500 characters for each post, forcing users to create those confusingly chronologically backward hellthreads that are interspersed and broken up in everyone's feeds, and there's many more deficiencies to list here.

This is why there are so many different forks.

When you create a #PeerTube account, you haven't joined the PeerTube network - you've joined the Fediverse!

When you create a #Pixelfed account, you haven't joined the Pixelfed network - you've joined the Fediverse!

If you create a mastodon account, you haven't joined "mastodon" - you've joined three Fediverse!

There is no such thing as a mastodon network!

It's just one type of Fediverse server platform, among many, like:

#Akkama, Pleroma, Friendica, #Lemmy, #Soapbox, #Misskey, PeerTube, #Mitra, Pixelfed, #MicroPub, #Epicyon, #Quanta, #GoToSicial, #Socialhome, #FunkWhale, and many many other platforms that open up the entire Fediverse to people, allowing them to share and seamlessly communicate with one another.

There are analogs for #Faceplant, #Twitter, #InstaSPAM, #Reddit, and pretty much any type of social networking experience you can find in the deprecated, centralized, legacy silo systems that cannot, and do not wish to interact with each other - which the Fediverse breaks the paradigm of, and empowers everyone engage with each other globally.

Mastodon's marketing has very deliberately been designed to subvert that narrative and replace this reality with its own, self serving commercial interests to the detriment of Fediverse itself.

A wake up call us coming very soon when the #non_FOSS based platforms like #Tumblr and #Imgur join their (millions) substantial user bases to the Fediverse at which time, mastodon itself may find itself drowned out and largely irrelevant due to its very lacking feature set, and ask if the other existing Fediverse platforms providing so much more if what is possible for us all.

This is typically what happens when your development is driven by egocentric, ulterior motives (whether he actually realizes this about himself or not) to benefit yourself personally - just look at how his donations have jumped, even though newcomers are creating accounts on other Fediverse and mastodon servers begging for donations that for the most part are going directly to him.

#tallship #FOSS #ActivityPub #introductions #newcomers

⛵

.

Mainstream media journalist: It's too hard to build an audience on Mastodon! I cross-post the same shouty posts and one-sentence slogans as I do on the fowl app, and they just get no traction here! It must be because it's just too complicated for people to read posts from other instances or something!

Me: Okay, do you follow many interesting people here?

Journo: No.

Me: Do you reply to posts and engage with other people?

Journo: No.

Me: Do you like and share many other people's posts?

Journo: No.

Me: Do you post anything interesting, insightful or funny? Or just shouty denouncements?

Journo: Oh, I don't just cross-post shouty posts and slogans — I also do self-promotion! Subscribe now to read my latest article!

Me: Could the problem be that you've relied entirely on an algorithm that's fine-tuned to incite people by distributing the most provocative content widely to generate ad views? That the core issues are that you don't engage, contribute little to the online community, and share little content of real value and substance? That you're essentially no different to the social media bullies you so often denounce in your paywalled articles?

Journo: No. The problem isn't me, the problem is Mastodon!

#TwitterMigration #Twitter #Mastodon

bei zeit-online raunt ein kommentator hinter der paywall, das buhei, das gerade bei twitter veranstaltet wird, könnte teil einer sehr gewieften, exzentrischen aber ausgefeilten strategie des ober-twits musk sein. und alle würden musk unterschätzen.

Möglicherweise aber ist manches von dem Chaos, das gerade bei Twitter zu herrschen scheint, auch Teil der großen Musk-Show. Er dürfte erwarten, dass interne Mails geleakt werden. Programmierer nach einzelnen Code-Zeilen bewerten zu wollen, könnte auch ein absichtlich exzentrischer Schritt sein. Man sollte Musks Fähigkeit zur Inszenierung nicht unterschätzen.

und bevor man fragen kann, wozu das gut sein soll, beantwortet der autor die frage nach dem zweck einer solchen inszenierung:

lohnt es sich im Hinterkopf behalten: Die vielen aufgeregten Tweets und Artikel sind erst einmal Aufmerksamkeit. Und je mehr Menschen jetzt von #RIPTwitter überzeugt sind, umso lauter kann Musk schreien I told you so, wenn die Plattform doch nicht stirbt.

eigentlich ist es kaum zu erwarten, dass twitter wirklich stirbt, wie der zeit-autor erwartet. myspace gibt es ja schließlich auch noch.

aber der journalist erliegt da wohl seiner sensationslust: aufmerksamkeit kann man deutlich besser und nachhaltiger und positiver erzeugen, als dadurch, dass man die hälfte seiner angestellten rausschmeißt und dann öffentlich behauptet, man sei als chef so gut, dass man die relevanten code-zeilen ihm unbekannter entwickler auf einen blick auf ihre qualität einschätzen kann.



#zeit #zon #twitter #musk #internet #fanboy