2022-05-03 22:54:20
2022-03-11 11:24:11
2022-03-11 11:23:50
283140
Open Letter to the international IT and telecom companies
You can read it sign it with the link above. However I never liked canned news so here is what it is all about and why it matters in my own words.
As sanctions keep piling up on Russia some of things here become increasingly restricted and this affects freedom of communication. Ironically this is the effect Putin wants - the government is busy building up their Internet censorship and control. Now as the result of some sanctions people trying to maintain independent services and censorship circumvention tools are under attack from both sides. Myself included.
Some examples:
Thawte certification authority suddenly revoked certificates of some services (banks mostly) which gave the government the reason to double down on imposing national certificate system. If successful it opens unprecedented opportunities for censorship and surveillance.
NameCheap domain registrar suddenly refused supporting customers from Russia forcing them to either move their domains immediately or lose them. This together with rumors of the government imposing isolation measures on Russian part of network made many people move their websites and services into Russian-controlled zone.
Some backbone ISPs like Cogent disconnected Russia impacting network connectivity and making it easier to shutdown, control and censor.
Visa and Mastercard payment systems withdrawing is probably the hardest blow for everyone who hosted something outside of Russia as there is no easy way to pay for services or receive donations for them. This also forces many people to migrate their projects back to homeland where they risk to be seized and their owners prosecuted.
While I understand the reasons for diplomatic pressure and public reaction to the events in Ukraine I can't believe this is the effect we want. This hurts the opposition, freedom of speech and access to information. I can't access some of the links above without VPN. Soon I likely won't be able to get on the global network without VPN - and not public one, these get blocked every day.
And the last thing - free social networks like this one are one of few remaining bridges between Russian and Ukrainian people. Mainstream networks are getting ugly, media sources get banned and blocked by the opposing sites. Here we still can talk. Hopefully it will last.
#NoWar #Russia #Ukraine
You can read it sign it with the link above. However I never liked canned news so here is what it is all about and why it matters in my own words.
As sanctions keep piling up on Russia some of things here become increasingly restricted and this affects freedom of communication. Ironically this is the effect Putin wants - the government is busy building up their Internet censorship and control. Now as the result of some sanctions people trying to maintain independent services and censorship circumvention tools are under attack from both sides. Myself included.
Some examples:
Thawte certification authority suddenly revoked certificates of some services (banks mostly) which gave the government the reason to double down on imposing national certificate system. If successful it opens unprecedented opportunities for censorship and surveillance.
NameCheap domain registrar suddenly refused supporting customers from Russia forcing them to either move their domains immediately or lose them. This together with rumors of the government imposing isolation measures on Russian part of network made many people move their websites and services into Russian-controlled zone.
Some backbone ISPs like Cogent disconnected Russia impacting network connectivity and making it easier to shutdown, control and censor.
Visa and Mastercard payment systems withdrawing is probably the hardest blow for everyone who hosted something outside of Russia as there is no easy way to pay for services or receive donations for them. This also forces many people to migrate their projects back to homeland where they risk to be seized and their owners prosecuted.
While I understand the reasons for diplomatic pressure and public reaction to the events in Ukraine I can't believe this is the effect we want. This hurts the opposition, freedom of speech and access to information. I can't access some of the links above without VPN. Soon I likely won't be able to get on the global network without VPN - and not public one, these get blocked every day.
And the last thing - free social networks like this one are one of few remaining bridges between Russian and Ukrainian people. Mainstream networks are getting ugly, media sources get banned and blocked by the opposing sites. Here we still can talk. Hopefully it will last.
#NoWar #Russia #Ukraine
like this
Jakobu, Meko #nowar, Theaitetos (Рцяэыоод), Iron Bug, sheetposter, Kazimierz Kurz, Max Kostikov, grey, Lumeinshin 3rd impact :asukaPout:, :8b_d: :8b_i: :8b_e: :8b_l: :8b_a: :8b_n:, Christoph S, 御園はくい, Leyonhjelm :ek2_ribbon: and Nanook like this.
reshared this
Iron Bug, sheetposter, Don, SoNak, dr-e 🛡️, jos, Som, Rusty Salmon :verified: 🐾 ☦, Evelyn fra denne andre øya and sim reshared this.
Kazimierz Kurz
•I appreciate any kind of honest and rightful Russian point of view. And understand Russian citizens are basically not responsible for such situation we have. But it is a consequence of Russia support for Russia government. And I do not see anything seriously harming for particular people in internet disconnected in Russia. You still have shelters, homes and food. It is just inconvenience or harm to your works for industrial complexes -/exactly this are goals of this actions.
So no, I feel no passionate for your inconvenience with Netflix accessing. Sorry.
Alexander
•Dozens (literally) of media websites got blocked in last ten days for calling it war. They are currently inaccessible for the vast majority of population without VPNs.
Also about 95-98% of public Tor bridges are currently blocked for the same reason. Not because you can buy drugs in Darknet - they were fine with that for decade - but because you can use it to read websites using the word "war". Or Ukranian resources. Including a couple of websites where you can look up your relatives in case they are KIA or captured.
About every other day another public VPN gets blocked too.
BBC is blocked. So is Facebook. So is Twitter. Many others too. Instagram joined them today. Guess the reason why.
So if y... show more
Dozens (literally) of media websites got blocked in last ten days for calling it war. They are currently inaccessible for the vast majority of population without VPNs.
Also about 95-98% of public Tor bridges are currently blocked for the same reason. Not because you can buy drugs in Darknet - they were fine with that for decade - but because you can use it to read websites using the word "war". Or Ukranian resources. Including a couple of websites where you can look up your relatives in case they are KIA or captured.
About every other day another public VPN gets blocked too.
BBC is blocked. So is Facebook. So is Twitter. Many others too. Instagram joined them today. Guess the reason why.
So if you like the idea of Russian people getting cut off from the global Internet - it means you want them not to use this word. Here is called "special operation". And some of censored websites are blocked using DPI and not listed as blocked. So it is called "network difficulties".
Fuck Netflix, seriously. Fuck Youtube even (still works, I suppose not for long). It is about accessibility now. It is about having different opinion.
To be honest I don't care about myself much. I will get by one way or another. I am scared about 140 million people here not being able to have different opinion. About them seeing what television said as true - enemies all around, nothing good out there, there be dragons.
Also let me to be blunt but it is absolute nonsense to think that things like that hurt industrial complex. Russia is well connected and basic infrastructure will work. They are designing it all this way because they want to be able to shut it down themselves. Severing dependencies only strengthens the isolation. It is not good for anyone.
like this
Max Kostikov, Wandering Thinker, mrostu, Lumeinshin 3rd impact :asukaPout: and creator of #fediblock :verified::makemeneko: like this.
reshared this
Alexander, govardhana, mayday, creator of #fediblock :verified::makemeneko: and Zerglingman reshared this.
Theaitetos (Рцяэыоод)
•https://twitter.com/AnnCoulter/status/1501723065708953606
I'm glad Russia is getting increasingly free from Western propaganda & soft power. Build your own things. You'll end up stronger in the long term.
Alexander
•EU by the way also thinks about increasing isolation talking about "EU firewalls", "chatcontrol" and other crap. If cutting links becomes the norm one day we will wake up each in their own North Korea.
Yesterday another backbone provider LINX cut off two largest Russian ISPs from the network.
Kazimierz Kurz
•Alexander
•It is bad for Russians.
And to some extent maybe it is bad for regime of Putin. Kind of. But not really.
If you want more Russian people taking anti-war stance you should let them know about the war not lock them down in their propaganda bubble. Not to mention that those who are in opposition are at greater risk now so doing things like this helps to decrease their numbers.
Kazimierz Kurz
•AFAIK Russians think Ukrainians bombarded his own cities to make fake war impression. It is not rationality can be changed by any kind of proof. It is therapist kind of problems.
I am nobody, so disputing with me is pointless. I just wrote what I think, with heavy heart, but I do not change my mind.
Jakobu
•Theaitetos (Рцяэыоод)
•That's the problem with most Westerners: Westerners believe their governments are stupid and just happen to make all these mistakes. "oops, there were no WMDs in Iraq", "oops, NATO expansion lead to the Ukraine war", "oops, cutting off Russia increases thought bubbles".
People in North Korea expect their governments lying to them. But stupid Westerners don't.
The West/NATO WANTS war with Russia. Our governments are EVIL. They WANT these things to happen. It's a feature, not a bug. Our governments pretend it's about "hate, disinformation, blabla", but it is all about CONTROL.
Do NOT seek to become a part of the West. The West is doomed. The West is an Evil Empire, the worst on Earth.
You're better off in Russia, even with all its problems. Compared to the West, you have a future in Russia. NATO/EU is collapsing. The Ruble is a stronger currency than the Dollar & Euro combined. The Western Empire is dying, which is why they're acting out so much, as they seek to impose their global control on the rest of the world, especially China (and Russia).
Do not expect anything from the West but absolute evil. The Ukraine is a fine example of what happens to those who become willing slaves to the Evil Empire of the West: it's a country rampant with (child) sex trafficking, poverty, corruption, violence, drugs, war…
The Ukraine currently is very similar to Russia under President Boris Yeltsin. Putin got Russia out of that mess back then and he will get Russia out of this mess again. You should not be against the war, you should ask China & India to join Russia in the war against the West.
Please defeat us. The Western population is so dumbed down and under total mind control, we can't free ourselves. I hope for Russia & China to crush NATO, so that we in the West can be FREE again!
dr-e 🛡️
•In the end, the Russians must free themselves from Putin.
Kazimierz Kurz
•Theaitetos (Рцяэыоод)
•Putin needs to free us from the Western Empire.
Kazimierz Kurz
•Alexander
•Meanwhile we can see how companies and individuals react. E.g. Thawte with their sudden revocation of certificates for political reasons greatly undermines their authority. CA is something that supposed to be trusted and reliable for anyone. Obviously they see their mission as something different. And NameCheap also shown their name does reflect the nature of their business :)
"Russia vs. West" - in my opinion anyone defeating anyone is utter nonsense. Today the world is in deep cultural crisis not to mention other global challenges. However you can't win over anyone by force or isolation. Cultural gravity and collaboration are the only way. Sadly Russia turned away from this route and these are consequences. The West seems to be devaluing these ideas as well. It won't bring us anywhere good in the long run. The Internet is already breaking up in islands.
As for "We will never end in that po... show more
Meanwhile we can see how companies and individuals react. E.g. Thawte with their sudden revocation of certificates for political reasons greatly undermines their authority. CA is something that supposed to be trusted and reliable for anyone. Obviously they see their mission as something different. And NameCheap also shown their name does reflect the nature of their business :)
"Russia vs. West" - in my opinion anyone defeating anyone is utter nonsense. Today the world is in deep cultural crisis not to mention other global challenges. However you can't win over anyone by force or isolation. Cultural gravity and collaboration are the only way. Sadly Russia turned away from this route and these are consequences. The West seems to be devaluing these ideas as well. It won't bring us anywhere good in the long run. The Internet is already breaking up in islands.
As for "We will never end in that position" - I certainly hope so, @Kazimierz Kurz, I wish noting ill for anyone. However I see some troubling signs all around and let me remind you that Russia went the road from "free speech and unregulated Internet" to "worse than China" in about 15 years. Not that much.
Iron Bug
•Стив Бьюкенон
•@heluecht@admin@friendica.utzer.de@andy@jbcarroll@rick@one@sonak@mrostu@produnis@wnymathguy@dre@webm@iron_bug@lightone@shuro@yura@govardhana@comcloudway@wthinker@bramanga@Som89@admin@friends.nogafam.es@smartbrain@jos@kostikov@mayday@Hyolobrika@poliverso@admin@friendica.myportal.social
Стив Бьюкенон
•Почему так мало сообщений в федерации, почему так мало других сообщений?
Alexander
•Что делать? Хотя бы не мешать тем, кто пытается что-то изменить или просто выжить. Основная мысль в этой записи такова.
Стив Бьюкенон
•@ru@heluecht@admin@friendica.utzer.de@andy@... show more
@ru@heluecht@admin@friendica.utzer.de@andy@jbcarroll@rick@one@sonak@mrostu@produnis@wnymathguy@dre@webm@iron_bug@lightone@shuro@yura@govardhana@comcloudway@wthinker@bramanga@Som89@admin@friends.nogafam.es@smartbrain@jos@kostikov@mayday@Hyolobrika@poliverso@admin@friendica.myportal.social
Iron Bug
•Стив Бьюкенон
•@produnis@... show more
@produnis@rick@one@andy@heluecht@jbcarroll@shuro
Стив Бьюкенон
•@produnis@rick... show more
@produnis@rick@one@andy@heluecht@jbcarroll@shuro
Kazimierz Kurz
•Alexander
•Yet it happened.
Splendor Solis
•But here I come to the second point, and I refer to Alexander - you do not consider one more side of the whole issue. Cutting off Russians from various social networks makes it difficult for trolls to sow disinformation and influence public sentiment. We experienced this to a very large extent in the first days of Russia's war against Ukraine. Every day there was a new "message of the day" in the m... show more
But here I come to the second point, and I refer to Alexander - you do not consider one more side of the whole issue. Cutting off Russians from various social networks makes it difficult for trolls to sow disinformation and influence public sentiment. We experienced this to a very large extent in the first days of Russia's war against Ukraine. Every day there was a new "message of the day" in the media, and even though the more informed people fought this disinformation, the majority still believed all this stuff. And frankly it seems to me that most people believe all this crap not because they don't have access to other information but because they are bombarded with disinformation either by the state media or by trolls who pretend to be ordinary people whose "auntie heard", "friend's brother-in-law saw" "auntie's best friend was a witness". And unfortunately for such people, if you show evidence that it is not true, it still does not change their mind. You have such people (Putin has reportedly 60% support) and we have such people too. So I don't know if access to the Internet would change anything. So far you have had access and support for Putin's actions is high and average people believe his lies. It seems to me that this access is being cut off precisely so that people in other countries are not exposed to this propaganda as well. Everyone has the right to believe what they want, but right now there is a war in which people are dying and the manipulation of public sentiment is not what we need.
Iron Bug
•Iron Bug
•Splendor Solis
•Iron Bug
•Iron Bug
•Iron Bug
•Splendor Solis
•Iron Bug
•Kazimierz Kurz
•Splendor Solis
•There is much talk in the world now about Polish aid for Ukrainian refugees, but the facts are that all this aid is provided by ordinary people, not by the authorities.
Max Mustermann
•The Great Russian Restoration
The Unz ReviewWalmart Official:verified: likes this.
Kazimierz Kurz
•Splendor Solis
•Kazimierz Kurz
•You simply has no knowledge to have opinion on this topics not mention commenting it.
There is 1 600 000 Ukrainian refugees in Poland now. It is impossible to help them without government coordination and help. We, Poles, are extremely efficient in such kind of events, we are people capable of making amazing things during such circumstances. This is our real superpower: organized cooperation in Solidarity way.
Splendor Solis
•Alexander
•And as I said there is even greater internal propaganda and disinformation. And ordinary people don't have fancy options to get through censorship. Restric... show more
And as I said there is even greater internal propaganda and disinformation. And ordinary people don't have fancy options to get through censorship. Restricting them from using VPNs, hosting services, etc means they are getting locked in the propaganda bubble. It can't be good for them and it can't be good for anyone else.
...
@Max Mustermann - I'd like to add that Russian mainstream social networks are under absolute government surveillance. If you look up criminal cases for extremism and other "words on the Internet" you'll see that about 70-80% percent of them involve VK. Either someone posted something there (even non-publicly) or there were some private messages or photos. These places are extremely toxic. You can find anything there - weirdest porn, underage escorts, all kinds of movements including very fringe ones, snuff videos, you name it. And at the same time everything is completely transparent to the police and other security services. These networks are plain dangerous to use, even accidental "likes" sometimes can cause prosecution.
...
@Hyolobrika AFAIK it was rejected outright. But yes, the idea is absolutely absurd. It would impact integrity of the Internet and surely cause annoyances for ordinary people but wouldn't disrupt Russian part of the Internet much as we have our own NS servers including root ones which would retain the copy of our zone.
like this
Wandering Thinker and Iron Bug like this.
Kazimierz Kurz
•Leyonhjelm :ek2_ribbon:
•Roh 👻
•Thank god we have bitcoin and other coins to pay.