qualified yes because I'm unsure what "counts" as planting. I've taken small trees from plant nurseries and dug holes for them and so on. I haven't ever like, started from a seed. Also, I've never done it alone. Really only ever helped someone else with the planting.
Qualified yes - it basically planted itself, probably a seed in a bird dropping, but in the wrong spot. So I dug it out and replanted a couple of meters further out. Have kept the tree since, about 20 years, the trunk is about 40cms diameter now… 🌳
Sure, had to make one. It’s a willow that in the cultured landscape around here is traditionally cut about man height bi-annually. I stick to the tradition, even though it’s in my garden instead of lining a field. What are yours (pic if no trouble)?
not even going to respond to the choices given as the pretext is doubtful, as other replies suggest.
Sure, move an already growing tree from one spot and put it in another - prob where something else was already growing.
Maybe you follow it up for years, maybe you forget you ever did it, and it has long since died.
Maybe you get government money, maybe you get a short warm glow. Maybe you learn something - prob best reason.
Having watched corporations get paid to slash hectares of 3 metre thriving wild trees and replace them with *similar* tree species in PLASTIC TUBES, I'm now super-sceptic.
But yes, I love trees and care-take all life phases of many that would not do so well alone, and they feed me.
I've only planted a few thousand in my 70 years. #Permaculture colleagues have planted 10,000 in one day (with a tractor-pulled planter) and millions over the course of their careers. Most people are slackers in this department, IMHO, though there is plenty of room for improvement.
Grew some pawpaw trees from seeds over the last two years. Planted six in the yard last summer, gave the rest away. Curious to see how they dealt with their first in-ground winter.
interesting. I have confession to make: when I first saw your polls, the questions were mostly about opinions and points of view, so I thought that "strong" means "I believe so" and "qualified" means "in my opinion", as in "my belief is backed by qualifications". A while ago I figured that my understanding of intended semantics was wrong, but I still continue voting like that 😁
here where I live in the western US, the National Arbor Day Foundation will give free trees away on Arbor Day. We have a small (but mighty) planetree now planted in the front yard.
My mom likes red maples and she used to grow them from seed, put them in small plant pots at first and keep them in the fridge for a few weeks in the winter, to get them used to cold. Then plant them in the ground after a year or two. We never stayed in one place long enough to see them mature. I've also planted trees; again, either moved away too sooon, or couldn't find a spot to plant them ( one got removed from where I put it. 🙁 )
Steve Scotten
•Jane
•jph
•bazkie bumpercar | unfluencer
•Steve Fenton ➜
•Vincent 🌻🇪🇺
•Evan Prodromou
•Vincent 🌻🇪🇺
•Trev
•Sure, move an already growing tree from one spot and put it in another - prob where something else was already growing.
Maybe you follow it up for years, maybe you forget you ever did it, and it has long since died.
Maybe you get government money, maybe you get a short warm glow. Maybe you learn something - prob best reason.
Having watched corporations get paid to slash hectares of 3 metre thriving wild trees and replace them with *similar* tree species in PLASTIC TUBES, I'm now super-sceptic.
But yes, I love trees and care-take all life phases of many that would not do so well alone, and they feed me.
Keith D Johnson
•Kirk Kittell
•https://www.instagram.com/p/CSCwjfUrTv6/
Kirk Kittell on Instagram: "Pawpaw trees at 15 weeks"
InstagramEvan Prodromou
•Acorn Squashbuckler
•Evan Prodromou
•It was interesting to see so many comments about what qualifies as "planting a tree".
For you final 15%: I highly recommend trying it out!
Jons Mostovojs
•A while ago I figured that my understanding of intended semantics was wrong, but I still continue voting like that 😁
Evan Prodromou
•Jons Mostovojs
•Thus, if there was a poll "Do you respond to @evan polls"? I would answer "Qualified yes" 😀
Bruno Girin
•Allison Clift-Jennings
•bjb :devuannew: :emacs:
•We never stayed in one place long enough to see them mature.
I've also planted trees; again, either moved away too sooon, or couldn't find a spot to plant them ( one got removed from where I put it. 🙁 )